Lucas Peterson

"The fried chicken sandwich is superior."

Scott Lynch

"Not as a hang out, necessarily—it can get irritatingly loud and crowded—but for its superb "Hot Breast" sandwich, a shockingly juicy hunk of spicy, crisp-fried white meat, a bit cool slaw and pickles providing the only condiments you'll need. Perfection."

Rayna Greenberg

"The best fried chicken sandwiches NYC: The Commodore - Hot Breast Sandwich - pickles and slaw."

Chris Crowley

"The great NYC sandwiches that aren't from Chick-fil-A: Chicken Sandwich from The Commodore."

Christine Amorose Merrill

"The service at The Commodore isn’t fantastic. But the spicy chicken sandwiches make up for everything – the food is out-of-this-world delicious making it one of those don’t miss places to eat in NYC!"

New York Sandwich Project.

"Slathered in pickles and slaw and a very flavorful, spicy sauce, it’s a fat, satisfying sandwich."

C&J Bus Lines

"Try their classic fried chicken sandwich (trust us, you won’t regret it)."

Donny Tsang

"Delicious sandwich."

Josh Pugh

"I had one of the best chicken sandwiches I’ve ever had in my life here."

Lee Breslouer

"This crispy, crusty, juicy chicken breast sandwich pays zero attention to the borders the bun tries to impose on it and delivers a significantly spicy flavor punch cooled and contrasted perfectly by the coleslaw and pickles topping it."