Rachel Lipton

"I normally don’t order pepperoni but the oven at Paulie Gee’s is so hot that the pepperoni curls up into roni cups which is basically pizza-crack. If you’re a pepperoni fan, don’t miss one of these pies – the crispy pepperoni is the ultimate game changer."

Devin Healey

"A greasy, cheesy masterpiece with pepperoni cups crisped to perfection and a firm crust that successfully captured any grease pockets and held up well to the classic fold. I threw on some hot pepper flakes, folded it, and was on my way. Without a doubt one of the top five best slices I’ve ever eaten"

101 Pizza Places

"These slices are just as good as any NY slice that we’ve had. Perfect amount of sauce and cheese."