Search locations or food
OR
Already have an account? Log in
OR
Key Lime Pie Co
Key West, United States of America
Recommended by Jane & Michael Stern and 8 other food critics.
4.4
73
Recommendations
"The Key West Key Lime Pie Co. will send you a magnificent, true, authentic Key lime pie. You can eat Key lime pie chocolate coated on a stick -- talk about heaven."
on Key Lime Pie
"This slice had a thin graham crust and overall is most comparable to a no-bake cheesecake. Being a cheesecake fan, I liked it. The best thing about a slice at the Key Lime Pie Co. is that they serve the pie straight from the tin—no single slices waiting in boxes—and they put the whipped cream on right in front of your eyes, fresh with every order."
on Key Lime Pie
"Best Places for Key Lime Pie in the Florida Keys: Key Lime Pie Co - The pies at the nationally award-winning Key Lime Pie Company are made fresh daily using natural ingredients, real Key lime juice, and handmade graham cracker crust."
on Key Lime Pie
"A Key West favorite, the Key West Key Lime Pie Company boasts award-winning pies that are made from scratch. They use natural ingredients such as real key lime juice, while the handmade graham cracker crust is hard to resist. Filling it with a light and smooth texture and the perfect amount of sweetness, they’ve got the winning recipe for the perfect ratio between creamy and crunchy."
on Key Lime Pie
"At the height of season, you might have to stand in line for a slice of key lime pie here, but it's worth the wait. These pies are national-award-winning, made fresh daily using natural ingredients such as real key lime juice and a handmade graham cracker crust. The result: a filling that's light and smooth, with just the right touch of sweetness, and a perfect ratio of creamy filling to crunchy crust."
on Key Lime Pie
"I have never in my life had a more satisfying slice of heaven than the key lime pie that I ate from the Florida Key Lime Pie Company."
on Key Lime Pie
"If you're in Key West and need a quick Key Lime fix, then stop in the Key West Key Lime Pie Co. shop and order up a slice of one of their freshly made pies."
on Key Lime Pie
"Now the pineapple coconut was out of this world! It was a heavenly mixture of coconut cream pie and key lime pie. So when in Key West, visit the Key Lime Pie Company for a slice of heaven."
on Key Lime Pie
Have you eaten at Key Lime Pie Co recently?
Are you the owner of Key Lime Pie Co?
Contact us and tell us more about your restaurant
editorial@tasteatlas.com
Contact us and tell us more about your restaurant
editorial@tasteatlas.com