Hollister "Holly" Moore

"Thanks to an internet search I found the best key lime pie in Key West - one of the best I've had this trip through Florida. Kermit's is packed with flavor."

Goldbely

"There are a few things that make up the perfect Key West experience—the sun, the sand, maybe some fishing… and Kermit’s Key Lime Pie. Made with their in-house double-strength key lime juice and topped with fluffy whipped cream, their classic Key Lime pie features a traditional graham-cracker crust and a rich, tart filling that is just scrumptious."

10Best

"Whether you have a classic slice of the tart confection with a dollop of whipped cream or dipped in Belgian chocolate on a stick, you'll quickly see why Florida named it the official state pie in 2006."

CBS Miami

"This is a truly traditional pie, with a rich graham cracker crust, smooth, tart filling, and dotted with whipped cream. The filling will make your lips pucker about, but that’s the best part of a great Key Lime pie."

Carina Ost

"Ten Best Key Lime Pies in the Florida Keys: Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - When it comes to the pie itself, it truly is the best. It's tart and rich, uses real key limes (not the Persian variety), and the graham cracker crust on the bottom is tops."

Alexandra E. Petri

"Best Places for Key Lime Pie in the Florida Keys: Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Made with all-natural ingredients and a delicious crust, this pie can also be served frozen, dipped in Belgian chocolate, and put on a stick."

Remington Brown

"Kermit’s key lime pie slice was just right. The texture was in the middle of being light/fluffy and dense/creamy, not overly fluffy and not overly dense. Just right. The flavor provided the perfect balance of tart and sweet with just enough whipped cream. The whipped cream also had the perfect smooth, whipped texture. To top it off, their crust was amazing."

Paige Wunder

"This was my #1 favorite! Their pie had this tartness to it that made my mouth pucker in the best way possible. Even though it was tart, it still was sweet enough and had the perfect texture."

Michele O'Connor

"One of the best places in Key West to taste key lime pie is Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe. After spending time wandering the store, be sure to buy a slice of key lime pie or try a frozen slice dipped in chocolate."

Helen Armitage

"10 Places To Get The Best Key Lime Pie In Florida: Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe has become a local institution since first opening in 1993 and its key lime pies (available in a classic-style or with strawberry) are a Conch Republic must-try."