Zach Brooks

"There's no better place to get one than the Town Hall Deli."

Kevin Alexander

"Only at Orange's Town Hall can you get the original Sloppy Joe. And guess what: it's not just a bunch of ground beef and ketchup. It's actually more akin to a triple-decker Reuben, with ham, tongue, and Swiss."

Andy Murdock

"The Town Hall Deli is the original and still favorite purveyor of the New Jersey Sloppy Joe -- it ain't cheap, but it's huge and designed to be split among several people so don't feel the need to tackle this one alone."

Dan Bergstein

"The sandwich can be found in a number of North Jersey delis, but its birthplace is The Town Hall Delicatessen in South Orange."

Ben Salmon

"Now, this is a Sloppy Joe. It was moist, not too dry, and the Russian dressing (apparently a carefully guarded secret recipe) was the best I had. I enjoyed "The Original," featuring ham, cow tongue and Swiss, which was amazingly delightful."