Michelin Guide

"A triple-decker wedge of red velvet cake sates all the sweet-loving guests."

Eater

"From the shakes to the towering red velvet cake, Eleven City only serves the most decadent (and enormous) desserts."

Amanda Topper

"We had our heart set on a slice of triple layer red velvet cake. The cake was so light and fluffy and the cream cheese frosting was rich but not overly sweet. In all honesty, it was the best red velvet cake I've probably ever had."

Dining Chicago

"Speaking of desserts that are red, it doesn't get any better than the red velvet cake at Eleven City Diner. This is the best red velvet cake in Chicago, with more red than a scene from Jaws. No bells and whistles required, just a solid slice of dense, hefty red cake pimped out with mercilessly rich frosting."

Matt Kirouac

"Be sure to save room for a hefty slice of red-velvet cake."

Michael Uzmann

"The highlight of the meal, a dense $8 slice of Red Velvet Layer Cake rife with dark cocoa notes but rendered mildly sweet and notably tangy by what might be the best cream cheese frosting in the Windy City.