Laura Siciliano-Rosen

"This traditional dessert has gooey, sweet molasses inside, a pastry bottom, and a light, powdery top. So sweet, but tasty!"

Malerie Yolen-Cohen

"Forget about that gooey, sickly-sweet stuff you endured on former trips to PA Dutch Country. Here, it’s amazing what flour, molasses and water can become."

Malerie Yolen-Cohen

"Dutch Haven sells more Shoo-fly Pie than all other bakeries in Lancaster combined. Why? Because it’s awesome."

Heesa Phadie

"The Dutch Haven has one of my favorite shoofly pies around and they’ll give you a free sample."

David "Sumoflam" Kravetz

"You also need to stop in Ronks and visit the Dutch Haven for some real yummy Shoo-Fly Pie. Gooey sweet goodness."

Namira Suada Bachrie

"If you are anywhere near Amish Village, please do stop by and look for the windmill and you’ll find that super good shoofly pie."

Christine Sarkis

"The Pennsylvania Dutch classic, a brown-sugar-and-molasses-based pie has an utterly unique rich, creamy flavor and a crumbly top, prompting one taster to exclaim, “it tastes like magic“.”

Beth Nicely

"I’m obsessed with this pie. It’s not too sweet and the crust to filling to topping was a perfect ratio."