Andrew Carmellini

"The pizza is good no question. The platonic ideal of a NYC pie, but it’s the shrouded mystery surrounding Dom snipping the basil over the top that makes the destination. Go with the pepperoni pizza".

Jason Concepcion

"Dripping with olive oil, just the right amount of cheese and sauce, the crust thin and blackened to a crisp, dotted with dime-size slices of pepperoni. It’s freaking incredible."