FoodieHub

"The Dutch lay claim to one of the earliest recipes for apple pie, and they sure do know how to bake a good crust… What’s more, the 17th Century Café Papeneiland serves up one of the best."

Jordan Hamons

"The pie at Cafe Papeneiland has a sweet, cakey crust and juicy, spiced apple filling with a sprinkle of raisins throughout."

Het Parool

"This ancient pub and national monument in Jordaan serves apple pie since 1642? Yes. Homemade, fresh and delicious."

Shoshannah Hausmann

"Best Appeltaart in Amsterdam: Café 't Papeneiland - The charming historic Cafe Papeneiland is also said to have the very best appeltaart in Amsterdam. Former US President Clinton even stopped in for a slice."

Amy Bingham

"This two-inch thick monument of marvelousness is every bit as delicious as it looks. The crust hits the sweet spot between flakey and doughy. The apples are delightfully tart without making you pucker and they maintain just a bit of their crispiness."

Rebecca Jackson

"The real highlight of the show in Café Papeneiland has to be the delicious apple pie. Not for the faint hearted, ordering a slice of apple pie will see that you get your week’s intake of treats – the portion is huge!"

Laura Owens

"Famous for its cinnamon and tart apples, Dutch apple pie is so delicious you may want seconds. Clinton did too - and he took home a whole pie!"