Search locations or food
OR
Already have an account? Log in
OR
Sweet Pie
Key Lime Pie
at Blue Heaven
Key West, United States of America
Recommended by Carina Ost and 13 other food critics.
KG
Recommendations
"The Florida Keys' Best Key Lime Pies: Blue Heaven - The pie’s base holds true to the classic recipe, but it’s the famously finicky and airy mile-high meringue that you can’t get anywhere else. Blue Heaven is so aware of its meringue’s fragility that the pie is only to be sliced by an experienced chef with a hot, wet knife to avoid collapsing."
"The Key Lime Pie at Blue Heaven in Key West might be the best you’ll try. Certainly their meringue takes the cake."
"Masterpieces indeed, the mile-high meringue crown is an impressive feat, and definitely had the most uniquely sweet flavor of all the pies we'd tried. Like taking a bite of a sweet and delicious key lime cloud, the sugary softness was the perfect counterpart to the tartness of the filling. Blue Heaven had the most beautiful meringue key lime pies we'd ever seen."
"The pie had the perfect balance of tartness and sweetness, and because Lemon Meringue Pie is my favourite, the similarities between the two immediately won me over."
"Ten Best Key Lime Pies in the Florida Keys: Blue Heaven - Some say meringue is part of the original key lime pie, but this one is some next-level stuff."
"Best Places for Key Lime Pie in the Florida Keys: Blue Heaven - This institution sells a Key lime pie made with 100-percent graham cracker crust and a light and airy filling, all piled high with fresh meringue."
"Of course, no visit to Blue Heaven is complete without ending your meal with a slice of their famous key lime pie. Made daily with fresh squeezed limes and a graham cracker crust, it is served with a heaping portion of meringue on top that is simply hard to resist for anyone with a sweet tooth."
"With a buttery crust and sweet, lightly citrus-flavored filling, Blue Heaven takes traditional key lime pie and tops it with three inches of melt-on-your-tongue meringue. For what the locals recommend as their favorite pie for visitors check out Blue Heaven."
"A Graham Cracker crust with a toasted meringue top that almost reaches heaven it is so big. Sweet and tart at the same time this Key Lime Pie gets 5 limes out of 5 from me."
"Florida's Best Key Lime Pie at Blue Heaven: The title may sound presumptuous, but with over 500 positive reviews on Google, many of which reference the incredible Key Lime pie, I think it's a justified statement."