Robert Sietsema

"Where to Find New York's Best Cheesecake: Two Little Red Hens - Dumb name aside, the TLRH's cheesecake is of the rustic sort, with a top well-browned to almost-crunchiness, a thick layer of graham cracker crumbs pleasantly sodden with butter, and creamy interior that turns out to be surprisingly mild."

Ed Levine

"Hers is the very definition of a phenomenal New York cheesecake; rich, light, and the perfect balance of sweet and tart."

Christine Knight

"Two Little Red Hens is known for their red velvet cupcakes. People (yes, sane ones) trek to their bakery from all over the city just for these cupcakes."

Carey Jones

"This Upper East Side bakery gets all the American classics just right — from cupcakes to chocolate chip cookies — so it’s no surprise its cheesecake is excellent, too, with a deeply browned graham cracker crust and a veritable tower of perfectly creamy filling. Wow, this is an absolutely perfect slice."

Gothamist

"The 10 Best Cheesecakes In NYC: Two Little Red Hens - Crowned with a stunning browned top and finished with a buttery, crunchy graham cracker crust, this specimen is a study in cheesecake textures. It's everything a New York cheesecake should be."

Christina Izzo

"The best cheesecake in NYC: Two Little Red Hens - This Upper East Side bake shop offers three rotating varieties, which currently include plain New York, cherry and pumpkin. The fruity toppings, cream filling and sweet graham cracker crust are all made entirely in-house."

New York Magazine

"Top 5 Cheesecakes: Two Little Red Hens - Rich and light with a touch of the tart, this version tames the usual cloying sweetness of standard New York cheesecake."

Robyn Hobson

"The Red Velvet knocked all previous RV contenders out of the park."

Simon Dang

"I have to give them the props for the presentation, just look at it – it’s amazing! The frosting was dead on."

Erik Seide

"Having frequented this establishment on many occasion, ExploringNY highly recommends that if available you try the red velvet cupcake which might be the best found in New York City!"