ABC News

"The cafe is famous for its buttermilk pie, a uniquely local and delicious dessert, created by its first chef, Lanita Franklin."

Daniela Galarza

"A major draw in Greensboro, Georgia, the Yesterday Cafe hooks pie lovers with its buttermilk chess pie. It's an addictive custard-chess hybrid where the tart, creamy buttermilk perfectly offsets the sweet, buttery base. Its burnished top is all that's needed; skip the whipped cream garnish."

Tamar Alexia Fleishman

"The Yesterday Café, whose award-winning buttermilk pie is rich, not overly sweet, but positively addictive."

Sue Rodman

"If you aren’t interested in the hand-pattied burgers or the salad with homemade croutons and dressings, it’s worth it to stop in for the buttermilk pie alone."

Lauren Cleland

"Arguably the most famous pie in Georgia, the Buttermilk Pie at Yesterday Cafe is so good that Southern Living named is one of the South’s Best Pies and Carrie Underwood ordered 300 for her wedding."

Priya Krishna

"What we do know about this treat is that it's a simple, custard pie made with egg, sugar, butter and flour (cornmeal and vinegar are also often in the mix), yielding a rich, gooey filling. Where to try: Yesterday Café in Greensboro, GA."