Search locations or food
OR
Sign up

WHERE TO EAT The best Sicilian Pizza in the world (according to food experts)

1
Recommended by Ed Levine and 13 other food critics.
"The crust is like no other. The bottom is plenty crisp, but the interior is tender and soft—it's airy, even though it has a tight-to-medium crumb. Where the cheese and crust meet, the two become one. The L&B Sicilian slice really is its own thing."
2
Recommended by Boston's Hidden Restaurants and 16 other food critics.
"The incredibly delicious squares of pizza."
3
Recommended by Scott Wiener and 9 other food critics.
"It’s unusual to see toppings on Sicilian pizza in NYC, but the incredibly popular Spicy Spring (a.k.a., pepperoni square) blows minds with its combination of fresh mozzarella, pepper-infused tomato sauce, and natural-casing pepperoni that cups and chars when baked. More conservative eaters play it safe with a Soho Square, which replaces the spicy sauce with a sweet and robust marinara."
4
Recommended by Adam Kuban and 5 other food critics.
"The crust is crisp, light, and airy, topped with plenty of sauce, a lot of Romano, and one rectangular slice of mozzarella. It’s a unique and delicious slice."
5
Recommended by Pete Wells and 5 other food critics.
"The squares, meanwhile, merge the Sicilian, Detroit, and Roman pizza al taglio styles in one dark, crunchy whole, fringed with what is known as a “frico crust” — the edges of browned cheese where the dough meets the pan. The pepperoni square in particular is an unstoppable force."
6
Recommended by Adam Goldberg and 4 other food critics.
"The crust is fairly spongy like a crisp, airy focaccia. Thanks to the deep, heavy pan in which it is baked, the underside is always on the fine border of crispy brown and burnt black, with just a hint of charred flavor adding complexity to the flavor. Sauce tastes slightly of pork fat and ground bits of pancetta, a blend that contributes to a meaty tomato sauce. Between the cheese and olive oil, this pizza packs just as much flavor as calories. And my, is it worth it."
7
Recommended by Scott Lynch and 4 other food critics.
"My favorite is Scarr's Sicilian slice, the thick crust surprisingly airy, the cheese (a "secret mix" of three types of mozzarella, with a sprinkling of parmesan for bite) charred to a magnificent chewiness, the fresh (not canned) tomato sauce ladled on in just the right measure. Scarr's Sicilian is right up there with best."
8
Recommended by Scott Wiener and 4 other food critics.
"This crust is crunchy on the outside and puffy on the inside. The pizzaiolos combine California tomatoes with sweet onion to match in flavor what the crust delivers in girth. It’s an incredibly satisfying slice that adds to the glorious surprise that is this hidden-in-plain-sight gem right across the street from Penn Station."