Andrew Zimmer

"Old Town’s wings are the kind of bar wings with enough tangy/buttery Buffalo flavor and substantial meatiness that you can house several orders and never get tired of them."

Sarah DiGregorio

"The wings here are small, very crisp, and saucy. They also have a distinct buttery aroma and velvety coating that indicates a whole lot of dairy fat in the mix. In short, they're delicious."

Dave Infante

"They're damn delicious, and this ancient Gotham tavern's unparalleled charm makes them a national treasure."

Lauren McKee

"Because their wings go directly from the fryer to the sauce, the flavor is absorbed, yet the skin stays supremely crisp. For the real wing traditionalist, Old Town Bar’s a very solid call."