Dan Myers

"Its English toffee and peanut brittle are legendary, but its old-fashioned fudge, in flavors like amaretto chocolate chip, rum walnut, coconut, blueberry, and cherry, is a showstopper."

Mary Jo Minarich

"Chocolate walnut. It was creamy and lots of nuts. Great chocolate taste!"

Dave Liske

"The soft caramel inside is amazingly smooth and not overly rich, having just the right amount of sweetness. And the chocolate is simply… It’s obvious May’s has tons of experience creating chocolate as this is some of the best I’ve ever eaten."

Laurie Kutil

"Speaking of fudge, let’s stop by May’s Candy Shop and see how the experts make it."