Robert Sietsema

"Where to Find New York's Best Cheesecake: Lady M Cake Boutique - The product is clearly inspired by the famed Sarah Lee frozen cheesecake of the last millennium, with a thin but well-oiled graham-cracker crust, a surreally dense and cool interior, and a signature layer of tart sour cream on top for added funk."

Carey Jones

"Silky and light in a way that none of the others are. Perfect cake-to-topping-to-crust ratio."

Brian Hoffman

"It’s been a while since I’ve had a slice with a graham cracker crust and this one also looked beautiful."

New York Magazine

"This version is miles ahead of the competition when it comes to freshness and sweet-tangy flavor."

Ray Chin

"Lady M Cake Boutique’s cheesecake (Gateau Fromage) is also up there among the best cheesecake in the city. Even though it is pricier than others on the list, it is well worth the visit."