Sabrina Crawford

"SAVING GRACE! As soon as I bit into the cake, it immediately started oozing! I couldn’t wait to devour it with cold milk. Getting a whole cake is the norm and is usually less than 10 bucks. It is a must have!"

Rachel Rummel

"Where to Try It: Federhofer's Bakery - This bakery has been in operation for more than 50 years and is said to make a Gooey Butter Cake that's similar to the original recipe."

Rose Hansen

"Where to try the best gooey butter cake in St. Louis: Federhofer's Bakery - Sticklers for tradition, the bakery avoids both cream cheese and powdered sugar in its take on gooey butter cake. This mom-and-pop bakery serves up gooey butter cake in five different flavors, slinging out more than 60 pans a week."