Devra First

"Desserts shine, too - a Giant Nutter Butter, two huge peanut butter cookies sandwiched together with whipped peanut butter filling and topped with coarse salt."

Nicole Fleming

"I love nuts. I love my almond croissants, my pecan pies, my peanut “nutter butter” cookie the size of a dinner plate at Sweet Cheeks Q, which you can pry from my cold, dead hands."

Leah Mennies

"The nutter butter has a really great, rich mousse in the middle. It’s a really classic nutter butter cookie that has some nice chew to it, and a nice amount of salt."

Liz Bomze

"Faison's whimsical take on the Nabisco classic features two thin, crisp cookies—each about 6 inches from edge to edge—flecked with coarse sea salt and sandwiching an ultra-creamy peanut butter filling."

James Lazaros

"The thin peanut butter cookies were packed full of peanut pieces. This dessert is for someone with a huge sweet tooth or to share with a group of friends. A great ending to our meal!"

Bites of Boston

"This cookie is truly as big as your face so sharing is encouraged…or not. Two chewy peanut butter oatmeal cookies with smooth, luscious peanut butter moose sandwiched in between and sprinkled with sea salt. Yes please!"

Paula Sokolska

"Composed of two peanut butter cookies, each the size of a dinner plate, this dessert definitely lived up to its name. A light, whipped peanut butter cream glued the thin, soft cookies together."