Dan Myers

"America’s 25 Best Fudge Shops: Original Murdick’s Fudge - Today there are several local Michigan locations as well as three stores and a bakery on Martha’s Vineyard, making fudge the old-fashioned way using copper kettles and marble slabs in full view of the adoring public."

John Gonzalez

"They make some of the best fudge on the Island."

Brittany Lyte

"Murdick’s Fudge shop, where fudge makers mold slabs of fudge and brittle crunch into melt-in-your-mouth morsels."

Maria Provenzano

"The art of fudge making at Murdick’s requires skilled fudge makers to perform a specific and timely “paddling” technique when shaping the delectable fudge into loaves."

Jennifer Gilbert

"If you prefer a more solid texture to your fudge, then Murdick’s 18 flavors are for you. The shop uses Michigan sugar in all of their fudge and features cherries from Traverse City in two flavors."

Lisa Renee Plunkett

"I’m not gonna lie, Murdick’s Fudge was our favorite even though it’s slightly grainier."