Dan Myers

"Huge and shatteringly-crisp, the lack of complete onion coverage leaves plenty of room for the onions themselves to caramelize."

Carly Petrone

"Move over delicious burgers and beer, and make way for the milkshakes over at Black Tap. The Cotton Candy takes you back to childhood, with a sweet strawberry shake base and toppings that look like a kid ran through a candy store."

PureWow

"The Best Milkshake in Every State: Black Tap - Brave the hour-and-a-half wait just to Instagram your $15 cotton-candy milkshake. Everyone’s doing it."

Tabelog

"The 13 Best Milkshakes in America: Black Tap - Describing the milkshakes at Black Tap Craft Burgers and Beer as extreme is an understatement. You basically have to see it to believe it."

Channaly Oum Phillip

"If you’re more of the onion rings type, don’t miss those."

Cate O'Malley

"The onion rings were awesome, definitely not frozen."

Margaret Abrams

"Nothing tastes as good as skinny feels--except for this milkshake."

Cavan Sieczkowski

"Black Tap’s outrageous milkshakes are heaven on Earth."

Chelsea Stuart

"America's Finest Milkshakes: Black Tap - Though lines have somewhat died down since their viral hayday, hoards of milkshake mavens still come out for their Sweet N’ Salty (with M&Ms, pretzels, peanut butter and whipped cream), Oreo Cookies & Cream, and Cotton Candy concoctions."

Mary Bowerman

"New Yorkers are going nuts over these over-the-top milkshakes offered by Black Craft Burgers & Beer. Garnished with lollipops, cotton candy, pretzels and more, there's something to satisfy every craving."